Anandtech published this summer two articles very critical of OS X Server's performance as compared to Linux:
- No more mysteries: Apple's G5 versus x86, Mac OS X versus Linux
The server performance of the Apple platform is, however, catastrophic. When we asked Apple for a reaction, they told us that some database vendors, Sybase and Oracle, have found a way around the threading problems. We'll try Sybase later, but frankly, we are very sceptical. The whole "multi-threaded Mach microkernel trapped inside a monolithic FreeBSD cocoon with several threading wrappers and coarse-grained threading access to the kernel", with a "backwards compatibility" millstone around its neck sounds like a bad fusion recipe for performance.
Workstation apps will hardly mind, but the performance of server applications depends greatly on the threading, signalling and locking engine. I am no operating system expert, but with the data that we have today, I think that a PowerPC optimised Linux such as Yellow Dog is a better idea for the Xserve than Mac OS X server.
- No More Apple Mysteries, Part Two
It is clear that if you plan to run MySQL on Apple hardware, it is better to install YDL Linux than to use OS X. If you need excellent read performance, the maximum performance of your server will be up to 8 times better. If your server is only going to serve a limited number of users, YDL Linux will allow you to run with a less expensive system.
If the usage pattern of your server is more OLTP, Transaction processing oriented, we give you the same advice. Our quick tests with InnoDB show the same kind of behavior and we have noticed very slow file system performance. At this point, we do not have enough data to be conclusive. We noticed, for example, that importing data in our database (via the ">" command) took up to 8 times longer.
Apple lost a sale last summer to one of my clients due to a lack of response on these articles. My Apple Xserve representative said that they were aware of the articles, but was told to say that there was no official response.
I still find the results quite mysterious -- is it only mySQL? Is it thread creation? What about Postgres which I don't believe uses threads.
Comments